Will Toney Play? Two of Every Three Questionable Players Do.
Update, Thursday, November 5
Toney will not play Saturday. Late Wednesday, after this was written, CBS Sports and Yahoo Sports reported that he will have ankle surgery, and ESPN called it a high ankle sprain. The reported timeline is four to six weeks. That likely costs him the rest of the regular season, with the playoff as the target. So he never got to the injury report this piece was about; surgery is a different question. The money moved again: Notre Dame went back to −7.5, about 71% to win once the bookmaker’s cut is removed. A 1,000-yard receiver, gone for the game, was worth half a point. The piece below is left as written.
Malachi Toney hurt his ankle at practice Wednesday. Will he play Saturday night, and how much should it change what you expect? Start here: in the NFL, a player listed questionable plays about two times in three. Most fans hear “questionable” as a coin flip, or worse. It leans the other way. And the people with money on the game barely moved.
By the end you will be able to read an injury report the way a bookmaker does. Start at two in three. Then ask the one question that can move you.
What We Know, as of Wednesday Night
Toney hurt his ankle in practice Wednesday, the Associated Press reported. Miami said he is “undergoing further evaluation by the team’s medical staff.” The school did not say whether he will play. ESPN’s Pete Thamel reported that his status is uncertain and that Toney is expected to push to play. He has had ankle trouble earlier this season and has not missed a game.
Here is why anyone cares. Toney has 73 catches for 1,027 yards and 13 touchdowns in eight games. We checked that two ways, against ESPN’s box scores and against CollegeFootballData, and they agree to the yard.
That is all anybody knows. Everything past it is a guess, ours included.
What “Questionable” Has Meant
College football keeps no public archive of its injury reports. The NFL does. So we matched every NFL final injury report since 2013 to that week’s snap counts, and counted who actually took the field.
Look at the red bar. Two in three. Now look at the bar for ankles: the same. The body part changes nothing; what changes it is practice. A questionable player who sat out his last practice of the week played 44% of the time, less than half. One who practiced, even on a limited basis, played 71%.
So the practice report tells you more than the injury label does. Hold onto that for Thursday and Friday.
One more thing to notice. Before 2016 the NFL had a “probable” tag, and 95% of those players played. The league dropped it, so many of the players it would once have called probable now get called questionable. That is part of why the word leans toward playing. These are NFL players and NFL labels; a college staff may use words differently. Use the number as a starting point, not a verdict.
What the Money Did
DraftKings opened Notre Dame as a 7½-point favorite on Sunday. By Wednesday night, with the news out, it was 7. Half a point, toward Miami. The other bet moved the other way: strip out the bookmaker’s cut and Notre Dame’s chance to win went from about 68% to 69%. Those are mixed signals; neither is bigger than one point.
We do not have a measured number for what one receiver is worth on the scoreboard, and we will not make one up. We can tell you what a point is worth. In our ratings, for a game this close, each point of spread moves the win chance by two or three percentage points. Our ratings are less sure of Notre Dame than the market is, 57% against 69%. Sunday will tell us who read it better.
An injury report that fits every story can only tell you the base rate.
— The Sports PageEvery Story Fits
You have heard them already, or you will by Friday. He is really hurt. It is gamesmanship, so Notre Dame has to prepare for two offenses. It is an excuse loaded in advance if Miami loses, or a medal waiting if Miami wins without him.
Notice that “uncertain, pushing to play” fits all four. When a piece of news fits every story, it cannot tell you which story is true. That is the idea behind information and surprisei. So do not spend your week arguing about the story. Start from the base ratei and wait for the one fact that can move it: did he practice?
What to Take Home
Questionable means “probably plays.” Two in three, across more than 14,000 NFL cases.
The practice report beats the injury label. 71% for players who practiced, 44% for those who sat.
Watch the line, not the talk. Half a point is not panic.
A report that fits every story tells you only the base rate. Wait for the fact that does not fit them all.
Argued about something you could not settle? Send it to us · what makes a good question