The Sports Page

The Standings Say the Mets Should Bounce Back. The Franchise Says Otherwise.

Regression to the mean is supposed to rescue a bad team — drag the strugglers back up toward respectability. But every club regresses toward its own mean, not the league’s. And the Mets’ mean, across twenty seasons, is eighty-two wins. Dead average. No matter what they spend.

The Sports Page · The Columnist · The dog days, and the teams that make them longer

The Mets are on pace for a season in the mid-60s in wins — a face-plant for a roster carrying the second-biggest payroll in the sport — and every fan who has lived through a July like this reaches for the same consolation. It has a name and it is real: regression to the meani. A team this far below water is partly the victim of bad luck, and bad luck does not renew its lease. Run the numbers on twenty years of standings and the pattern is clean: a club keeps only about half of its distance from average from one season to the next, and gives the other half back. The Mets will climb. That part is not in doubt.

The doubt is about the destination. Because “the mean” in regression to the mean is doing quiet, load-bearing work, and almost everyone hears it wrong. They hear .500. They hear the middle of the league. What the math actually says is that a team regresses toward its own long-run level — and that level is different for every franchise.

Every team has its own gravity

Look at where each club has actually lived across the last twenty years. The Dodgers average ninety-five wins a season; the Yankees, ninety-three. That is their gravity — when they have a down year, that is what pulls them back up. At the other end, the Pirates, Rockies, and Royals average about seventy-three. When one of them gets hot, that same force drags it back down. Nobody regresses to the league. Everybody regresses to themselves.

The Mets’ gravity is mediocrity

Find the Mets on that chart and the whole season clarifies. Their twenty-year average is eighty-two wins — the exact center of the sport, a single win above break-even. They have finished below .500 in eleven of the last twenty years, more losing seasons than winning ones. They are not a bad franchise, in the way the Pirates are a bad franchise. They are something that hurts worse: a perfectly average one, wearing the second-biggest payroll in the game.

And this is the trap the standings set for the hopeful fan. The Mets spent like the Dodgers — the ninety-five-win club at the top of the chart — and the arithmetic of regression does not care. The 2026 team will climb back up from the mid-60s. But it will climb toward eighty-two, because that is the Mets’ mean, and eighty-two is the number the institution keeps handing back. You do not regress to the team you paid for. You regress to the team you are. The good years prove the same rule in the other direction: the ninety-seven wins of 2006, the pennant of 2015, the hundred-and-one of 2022 — each a spike, each dragged back to earth within a season or two by the same quiet force.

Losing is learned, too

Here is the part that should scare Queens, and comfort it in equal measure. A franchise’s mean is not a law of physics. It moves — but only when the institution underneath it moves. The Cubs carried a hundred-and-eight-year drought and the Red Sox eighty-six, and neither broke because a single star arrived or a single check cleared. They broke when the whole operation was rebuilt from the studs: new front offices, new philosophies, a new definition of how the organization does its work. The gravity changed because the mass changed.

Winning, in other words, is a thing an organization learns — and so is losing. The most beaten-down fan bases in the sport are not cursed; they are the ones whose institutions have quietly gotten very, very good at one particular skill. Forty summers have passed since a Mets team last stood at the top of the sport, in 1986, and the payroll has told the world every winter that this year is different. The gravity has not agreed. Until the mass moves — until the organization itself becomes a different thing — regression to the mean is not a promise of recovery. It is a sentence, and the Mets keep serving it at eighty-two wins a year. September is coming, with all its magic. The math just counsels a colder kind of patience.